Evaluate the account of Fa Hien as a source of history of Ancient India. How his account can be compared with the account of Hiuen Tsang? [15 Marks]
Nidhin R H, AIR 699, 2025
Fa Hien was a Chinese pilgrim who visited India in search of Buddhist books and traditions in the period of Chandragupta II. He visited places like Shravasti, Pataliputra, Sarnath etc. and made elaborate recordings in "Record of Buddhist kingdoms"
Account of Fa Hien as source of history
Fa Hien makes accurate observations of Indian society and traditions.
1. Social conditions: India as a peaceful country, free of theft. There was no cruel punishments very severe crimes get amputations. Fa Hien notes plight of chandalas who resided outside cities and entered by making noise. 2. Economic conditions: He speaks of climate of India, Various crops etc. India was a rich country and people compelled to do charity. 3. Religious conditions: Klide tolerance existed. Very detailed account of traditions, customs and myths.
His observations give a third person's view of India of the times. It aided historians to reconstruct India as the beliefs of people got recorded.
But, there were severe limitations. 1. Fa Hien's presence an idealistic view of Indian society, far from reality eg: No crimes, no drinking etc. 2. Fa Hien was only focusing on Buddhist aspects of India, though he mentions other religions. He do not even mention the ruling king's name. His idea was probably to inspire his readers in China to live an idealistic life on Buddhist terms.
In comparison with Huan Tsang, 1. Huan Tsang wrote his account after going back to China, thus avoiding biasness to India. eg: He mentions being robbed twice. 2. Huan Tsang's accounts are more comprehensive and detailed. - economic, social, political aspects too. 3. But, unlike Huan Tsang, Fa-Hien does not get associated with Indian kings, avoiding some biasness eg: Huan Tsang presents idealistic picture of Harsha.
However, we have to understand that both accounts were written from a religious angle, centuries apart. This also allows us to compare progress of Indian society from Guptas to post-Guptas.