Q.3 (b) "On circumstantial evidence Indra stands accused." Discuss the given statement in the context of the decline of Harappan Civilisation. [15 Marks]
Nausheen, AIR 9, 2023
The given statement is made in context of Indra causing the decline of Harappan civilisation.
Decline of Harappan civilisation - Mortimer wheeler argues that Harappan civilisation was destroyed by Aryans as there is reference of Indra - as destroyer of forts in Rig Veda. - He also identifies 39 skeletons in Harappan cultural mound arguing that they were killed during skirmishes with invading Aryans. - Moreover, he identifies Harappa as Hariyupiya mentioned in Rig Veda.
This proposition has been refuted by BB Lal and GF Dales on various propositions :- 1. The 39 skeletons found in Harappan cultural layer do not belong to the same period. They were of different period. - The arguments of wheeler is not substantive as it is based upon Vedic texts without any clear archaeological evidence. - There is clear evidence of later phase of Harappan culture. This suggest gradual waning of urban phase of civilisation and begining of rural phase with eastward expansion.
Other reasons that could have caused decline are :- 1. Flood theory by GP Dales, R.Raikes :- They argue that fracturing in the earth caused Indus to change its course leading to flooding of Harappan civilisation. 2. Environmental changes → Pollen analysis of yudip singh presents the case of drier weather that prevented production of crops. 3. Exploitation of resources : The resources in Indus region was constantly exploited by people resulting in the inability of the area to sustain the population.
However, no single factor can explain the cause of Harappan decline comprehensively. Rather, one should see a gradual shift from urban Harappan culture to rural post-Harappan culture that expanded eastward.