Q.2 (c) What were the factors responsible for the rise and decline of the republics (Ganas or Sanghas) during the time of Gautam Buddha? Were they democratic in nature? [20 Marks]
Nausheen, AIR 9, 2023
During the time of yautama Buddha, two types of polities were present - monarchies and republics. The sources for the period are : Sutta Pitaka, Vinaya Pitaka, Sutta Nipata, Milidapanho, Asthashastra of Kautilya etc.
Factors for their rise
[a small outline map of India marking the mallas and sakyas, captioned "ganas or sanghas"]
1. Political factors - They were formed against the monarchical state. - Formed as the result of subversion of monarchical rule. 2. Social factors - They represented some vestiges of tribal organisation which had not yet integrated into monarchical structure. - They also represented Kshatriya reaction to Brahmanism as gana-sanghas were led by former while monarchies were led by latter. 3. Economic factors The emergence of city life caused huge differentiation in wealth of population. These inequalities were not liked by few sections of the society who formed republics.
Factors leading to its decline 1. Political reasons . - Gana-sanghas were form of corporate organisations. The decisions were taken by few elites in otherwise large assembly. - There was no voting system for the selection of rulers and later it became hereditary 2. Military reasons - They did not have large standing army and were mostly overpowered by the monarchies. 3. Internal reasons Since the decisions in republics were collectively taken through discussions, they were susceptible to internal disient. Arthashastra tells about this method to overpower them. 4. Social reasons. The ganas or sanghas were led by Kshatriya families only. Brahmans and other varnas were not allowed to take part in the assembly. For instance; Upali, the barber of Sakya kingdom could not take part in the assembly. 5. Economic reasons. These ganas - sanghas were present at the bases of hills, outside the fertile zone, this prevented them in developing agriculturally.
There has a debate among historians about the nature of these polities. Nationalist historians like KP Jayswal, exagerated the republic element of these ganas and sanghas. This was done to prove the presence of republic ideals in ancient India . However, few of their features were undemocratic too . - They were ruled by elites amongst the larger assembly. - Did not include all castes and economic groups. - no voting system in election of rulers of these polities. - no means of presenting grievances to the elite assembly.
All these factors led to their usurption by the monarchical. states but they were certainly a move by ancient people in India to form a democratic structure .