Q.2 (b) Critically examine the impact of Iron technology on post-Vedic ancient India. [15 Marks]
Nausheen, AIR 9, 2023
Post vedic ancient India ( 6th c. BCE onwards ) witnesses second urbanisation. It is often being argued that iron contributed to it immensely.
Iron Technology and its impact - According to historians like R.S Sharma, D.N. Jha, the gangetic plains were cleared using iron tools. This area was densely forested area which didn't allow its inhabitation as wooden or copper-bronze tools could not be used in clearing it. with coming of iron technology, these areas were cleared making room for urbanization. - This provided fertile plain for cultivation and iron tools were used in ploughing the field.
However, this proposition has been refuted by historians such as Nihanranjan Ray, Ranbeer Chakrabarti and DK Chakrabarti on following grounds :- 1. Iron ploughshare has been food at only four places -> Jakheda, Atranjikhera, Vaishali and Ropar. This does not reflect its wide usage leading to the clearance of field 2. Also, the forested areas could very well be cleared with copper-bronze tools and fire as was done for Khandava forest of Mahabharata. 3. Mere presence of iron cannot be the guarantee of its usage unless some central direction is provided for producing surplus. The mahajanapadas that emerged in 6th c. BCE provided this central direction.
[a sketch map of India with Ujjain, Magadha, Kashi and Ashmaka marked, captioned "mahajanapadas in 6th c. BCE"]
Thus, the debate on iron remains inconclusive. However, it was certainly one of the factors contributing to the rise of cities in 6th c. BCE.