Topper Copies

'Clive was not a planner of empire, but an experimenter who revealed some of the possibility.' Critically examine.

Kaushik Mishra

Robert Clive played a crucial leadership during the establishment years of East India Company from merchants to masters in India.

Clive was not a planner but experimenter

A. As he responded to the prevailing situations rather than planning such situations. Eg: Discontent in Bengal prevailed between Nawab, military chiefs Eg Mir Jafar and businessmen like Jagat Seth. Clive only utilised the situation.

B) Critical Analysis

- Showed multiple skills of diplomacy, conspiracy and military leadership which is part of a planned technique. - Prioritied Economic growth along with military Conquest. to avert the challenges like French Eg: Carnatic Wars. - Portrayed leadership from front line to keep soldiers motivated. - Imposed 'Dual Government' in Bengal to ensure fixed income without any responsibility. Eg: Gave Nizamat functions to puppet Nawab, while retaining Diwani rights

Hence these qualities show that Clive was planner though his success of his plans in long term are debatable among historians due to mix of success and failures For Example Dual government failed but Br foundation of British Empire was laid successfully.