"The establishment of British rule led to the complete ruining of traditional industries (handicrafts) in India." Critically examine.
Nausheen, AIR 9, 2023
Economic critique of British rule in India included the thesis that the establishment of British rule in India led to de-industrialisation.
Complete ruining of traditional industries
- Removal of patronage : the destruction of indigenous states led to the removal of patronage to artisans and craftsmen as they used to cater to the demands of nobility and ruling class. - Divulging of trade secrets : The artisans were forced to divulge their trade secrets to British. They were made to sell cheap and buy dear. - Industrialisation in Britain. This resulted in overflowing of cheap machine made goods to India. The tariff structure of railways was such that the goods from ports to interiors were cheaply brought and raw material from interior to ports were cheap. Also, the British government had raised the tariff for goods coming from Britain due to fear of competition to home made goods. - Education policy Westen education was introduced in order to make them "good consumers" "brown in colour but English in taste". This led to the fall in the demand of indigeneous products.
De-industrialisation has been a matter of debate amongst historians.
- British historians argue that, even when the cheap-machine goods started coming to India, There were artisans who supplied coarse goods for satisfying the interests of lower strata. - They also argue that there is no significant data to quantify the extent of de-industrialisation.
This view has been also supported by Tirthankar Ray. However, the percentage of population involved in industrial sector in Bihar fell from 18.6 % to 9.4 % in 20 years. The increase in per-capital remuneration was because of the specialisation of artisans. This de-industrialisation is the major cause behind India remaining a developing country till now.