"The proposal of the Cripps mission was departure from the past but not acceptable to Indian leaders." Critically comment.
Nausheen, AIR 9, 2023
Cripps Mission was sent to formalise the August offer. It included three British MPs.
Departure from the past
Cripps Mission offered dominion status to India after war. It also gave the choice of joining or refraining to join the Commonwealth. Regarding provinces, they were given the right to secede and to form their own constitution. Thus unity of India was no longer a pre-condition. It gave the right to form constitution with representatives from provinces and princely states. It also gave Indians the right of governing themselves with Viceroyship and defence in remaining in British hands.
Not acceptable to Indian leaders
- Congress rejected the dominion status, no participation in defence relations; policy making of the government and nomination by the princely states. Also, the right to secede given to provinces undermined unity of India. - Similarly, Hindu Mahasabha rejected the demand as their vision of "Hindu rashtra" was threatened by this. - Ambedkar rejected it as the rights of depressed classes was not secure.
JL Nehru commented, that Cripps Mission provided a " post dated cheque to of India a failed bank " to India.