Topper Copies

Critically Examine the statement that French revolution was not caused by the French philosophers but by the conditions of national life and by the mistakes of the government.

Kaushik Mishra

French revolution began in 1789. It was based on the idea of justice, equality, liberty, etc and aimed to replace old monarchical regime with new regime of republic governance.

Role of French philosophers :

- Acted as catalyst in awakening masses of the contemporary situation - Provided leadership in during the revolution. for Example. - Voltaire awakened masses about 'corrupt Church by declaring - Churches are not infallible - Act as 'Dens of Superstition' - Montesque propogated ideas of Sepration of power and rull of Law - J.J Rosseau explaind 'Social Contrat Theory' hence popularised 'Romanticism' - Mirabeau propogated equality etc.

Conditiondition of National life :-

However the real reason / foundation-al problem lied with nation life.

- Privelige based Society is divided in 3 Estates

- Absense of Judicial System driven by Corrupt practices of Church Eg: 'Lettre de Cachet' 'Letter of Indulgence' and Monarchy. - Agriculture in stagnated state. - No signs of Industrial development - Faulty Taxation System Eric Hobsbawm → 45% of income went to Taxes.

| Estimate | Share | |---|---| | Tithe of Church | 14% | | Jille | 47% | | Gabble, Fodclerct [?] | 10% | | Tax | 71% |

- No support during Famines Eg: 30 famines between 1700-1789 → Henry Lefebvre

Mistakes of the government :-

- Extravagance on Royal Upkeep Eg: 11% of National income - Indulgence of in unnecessary wars Eg: American wars Costs 4 £54 Million Lives. - Apathy towards masses and their misery Eg: on Bread riots Marie Antonnet's statement 'why not eat cake?' - Not providing proper representation to Third Estate Eg: Estate general unequal voting powers and irregulary organised like after 175 years

These conditions became the foundation on which philosophers constructed the building of revolution. Hence were not solely responsible for it.