Indo-Pacific in recent times has emerged as zone of diverging interests and priorities. Discuss. Do you think Global Security Initiative will supercede Quad in the region?
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
The Indo-Pacific has emerged as the new theatre for global cooperation, collaboration, competition and conflict, as it lies along several of the major geopolitical "arcs" - such as the "arc of communication" (SLOCs).
Diverging interests and priorities 1. Chinese resistance/issues with Quad. 2. Chinese opposition to a "free and open, secure and prosperous" Indo-Pacific 3. Diverging views on Taiwan 4. Potential disruption possible from the multiple Sea Lanes of Communication 5. Territorial disputes in South China Sea 6. Differing views/priorities on using oceanic resources - (eg.) whether to use deep sea gas reserves 7. Different priorities for connectivity projects: - China: Belt and Road Initiative - USA: Indo Pacific Economic Forum (IPEF) - India, Japan, etc: priority to smaller projects, such as India-Africa Growth Corridor 8. Different priorities for developmental approach: China's Beijing Consensus vs USA's New Washington Consensus
Global Security Initiative (GSI) 1. New initiative proposed by China 2. Focused on "joint security" / "indivisible security" 3. Against the process of sanctions 4. Opposing unilateral actions 5. Opposing hegemonic practices
Can the Global Security Initiative supersede Quad? While the principle of GSI is undoubtedly noble, it is not trusted by the rest of the world, as it comes from China: 1. The principle opposes unilateral actions → yet China undertakes such actions routinely 2. Principle opposes hegemony → yet China wants regional hegemony for itself 3. Principle is about joint security → yet China routinely violates the security of others - (eg.) border with India, South China Sea, etc.
Hence, due to these contradictions, GSI can never supersede other organisations.
Yet, if the principles of GSI were to be proposed sincerely, its principles may become successful one day.