Evaluate Tarikh-I Firuz Shahi written by Shams Siraj Afif as a source of medieval India.
Nausheen, AIR 9, 2023
Tarikh-i- Firozshahi was written by Shams Siraj Afif after the death of Firuz Tughlaq, in 1390. It talks about the reign of Firuz Tughlaq. Tarikh-i- Firozshahi was one in the series of books written on Ghiyasuddin Tughlaq, Mohammad Bin Tughlaq and Firuz Tughlaq.
Evaluation of the book as source of medieval India :- 1. Genuine account • It was written by Afif after interacting with the Sultan individually. Thus it is more authentic than other primary sources of the time like Tarikh-i- Firozshahi by Barani 2. Description of the times of ruler - (i) Political and Military - It is the only source that mentions about his failure against Ilyas Shah in Bengal. It is mentioned that he was defeated twice and thus was not a able general. - (ii) Administrative Description - (a) Afif mentions about his farm-reforms like improvement of cropping pattern, sondhar loans, etc. - (b) His efforts in the development of Rajabwah by irrigation activities. - (c) His new slave department of duwan-i-bandagan is also mentioned. - (iii) Economic description - Afif mentions about royal karkanans under which slaves used to produce articles and goods for nobility. It also mentions that wages were regularly provided to them. - (iv) Architectural description - (a) In his book, Afif describes how Ashokan pillars were brought from Meerut and Topara and installed in Delhi. - (b) He also mentions about gardens constructed by Firuz. - (c) Taj-i-Ghariyat - water clock has also been mentioned in it.
However, caution needs to be exercised in using it a source due to following reasons :- - (i) "Royal authors are only half authors". Hence some of the facts might not be correct. For e.g. his description of the city of Delhi being the most prosperous in the world. - (ii) He showed Firuz as a pious Muslim which may or may not be correct. As royal authors are usually trained by ulama, they may say so always.
Thus use of such literary sources needs to be done with caution, substantially with other accounts of the times.