Topper Copies

Critically examine the debates among historians regarding the applicability of the term 'Indian Feudalism' to early Medieval Society.

Nausheen, AIR 9, 2023

Early Medieval society in India ( roughly from 700 AD - 1200 AD) has been mired in controversy regarding its nature. The basis for which is whether there was feudalism in India or not.

Indian Feudalism Theisis This was given by Marxist historians like RS Sharma, DN Jha. They argue that due to wide prevalence of land grants given by royal families to the nobility, feudalism developed. -> These land grants resulted in de-centralisation of powers, a decline of urban centres and rural self-sufficiency prevailed in the areas of land grants. -> Due to the decline of urban centres, trade relations also were lost and de-monetisation of economy took place. -> They base their theisis on 'vishti' (forced labour) and police powers given to the nobility on in areas granted to them ; This theisis has been criticised on various grounds by historians like Ranveer Chakrabarti, Upinder Singh etc.

CRITICISMS - The land grants were made by some of the most powerful rulers. Questions are raised as to why would they themselves erode their power of influence. - These land grants were given to Brahmans who used to construct royal genealogies for the rulers that helped them legitimise their rule. - Historians like Harbans Mukhia in his paper "Was there Feudalism in India" has criticised the notion that through facts like :- - The peasants were not tied to the lands. - The feudal lords were not obeliged to their rulers for military services.

Criticisms on de-urbanisation while some of the old urban centres declined, new emerged during the period too.

| Old centres | Vaishali, Taxila | |---|---| | New Centres | Banaras |

Criticisms on de-monetisation of economy The theisis is based mainly on the coury-shell and debasement of coinage. This can be countered with the facts that :- -> coury shell was used as token currency for long distance trade. The value ratio being 1:1290 (approx) with the actual currency. -> debasement of coinage does not mean decline in economic activities rather a proliferation of it.

Criticisms on decline of trade - The local trade continued to exist though periodic markets like hattikas and mandis, according to Ranbir chakrabarti. - Long-distance trade too continued even after decline of Roman empire, with south east Asia and Byzantine empire.

Thus, the theisis of feudalism cannot be applied to Indian context, rather models like Segmentary state by Southall and State societies proliferation (by BD Chattopadhyay) are better models for it.