China views India as "Asian Rival" with innate ability to counter its hegemonic goals in Asia. Despite these difficulties in India-China relations, there are also convergences. Discuss.
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
India believes that all countries have their own journey, and the world needs collaboration to resolve global issues, which naturally leads to multipolarity, and absence of any hegemony.
China, though, with its objective of hegemony, is thus fundamentally against the concept of equity and absence of hegemony.
This has led to various difficulties, such as: - Security: border - Economic: dumping of goods; looking into criminal activities by Chinese businesses - Multilateral: China becoming "global protector of terrorism" (blocking proposals to list terrorists at the UNSC 1967 committee)
and so on.
Yet, there are areas of convergence:
(I) Economic 1. Biased functioning of Bretton Woods institutions - (eg.) US has 15%+ shareholding in IMF, and major proposals need 85%+ votes to pass, effectively giving USA a veto 2. Biased credit rating agencies 3. Hegemony of US dollar in global trade → de-dollarization of the world 4. Doha Development Agenda at WTO, and subsequent Peace Clause on agriculture
(II) Socio-cultural 1. Against blind "westernization" of society 2. Against western societal ideas and values eroding indigenous ones
(III) Multilateral 1. Peace and stability in the region → cooperation via SCO (Shanghai Cooperation Organisation) and its Permanent RATS (Regional Anti-Terrorist Structure) 2. Cooperation with other developing nations at BRICS - (eg.) BRICS proposal to set up its own rating agency
(IV) On climate change 1. Belief that contribution to resolve climate issues should be proportional to cumulative historical emissions, not just present emissions 2. Climate finance for developing nations
(V) Industrial complementarities 1. India as a market for China 2. India as a destination for Chinese businesses to move to, considering rising cost of manufacturing, labour, etc in China
Thus, there are several areas of convergence. Yet, as the honorable Defence Minister has clearly said, "Cooperation between the 2 nations can progress ONLY if peace and tranquility is established on the border"