"Neo-liberal reforms and globalization have deeply transformed institutions of welfare state and set the ground for a new type of civil services". In this context, examine challenges faced in service delivery and suggest reforms.
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
Neoliberalism is an economic-political theory relating to low state intervention in society and economy, with the state mainly playing a regulatory role. It has increased in the phase of globalisation seen post the Cold War.
Challenges for public service delivery 1. Delays in decision making → delay in service delivery → red tapism: state institutions are slower than non-state institutions created by neoliberalism and globalisation. 2. Lack of political will/conflict of interest in political will, due to vested interests in non-state profit-making organisations 3. Governmental confusion in type of schemes to fund → capital expenditure v/s revenue expenditure 4. Distractions due to resource allocations: neoliberalism and globalisation → resources consumed rapidly → resource inequality, shifting focus away from core welfare initiatives even as the state needs to step in for equitable access - (eg.) inequity in access to water: "water in 21st century could be like what oil was in 20th century - a source of wealth and conflict" - Brahma Chellany 5. This is leading to focus shifting away from health, education, etc. 6. New challenges of climate change, terrorism, etc. 7. Lack of public participation.
Reforms to resolve aforementioned challenges 1. Faster functioning of govt: leaner structure, i.e, lesser levels of decision making → clearly defined roles → effective delegation → focus on work culture 2. Transparency in disclosures of public representatives and bureaucrats, to prevent potential conflict of interest ("Sunlight is the best disinfectant") 3. Policy on budgetary allocation, instead of ad-hoc decision making → output outcome budgeting, performance budgeting 4. Focus on equity in access to basic resources - Economic Survey suggested a Bare Necessity Index. 5. Collaboration with pvt sector and civil society on welfare initiatives - (eg.) CSR, NITI Aayog Darpan Portal, etc. 6. International collaboration to resolve global issues - (eg.) terrorism, climate change 7. 2-way public participation - (eg.) my GOV. Mission Karmayogi must ensure that it takes into account the aforementioned challenges, to make the bureaucracy future-ready.