"Harshvardhan was himself great, but he has been made greater by Ban and Yuan Chiang." Critically examine.
Abhijnan Hazarika, AIR 172, 2023
Harshavardhan occupied the throne of the Pushyabhuti dynasty around 606 AD and ruled till 647 AD with the capital at Kannauj.
Greatness of Harsha Political conquests - occupied almost whole of North India - Bengal by defeating Gaudas - merging Kannauj with Pushyabhuti dynasty - subduing feudal lords
Socio-cultural - Philanthropic activities - organised an event every five years and donated all his earnings - donations to Brahmanas, monasteries etc. - gave 100 villages for the upkeep of Nalanda University
Accounts of Hieun Tsang - tells that his army consisted of 8 lakh footsoldiers, large number of elephants - clearly overexaggerated - doesn't talk about defeat in the hands of Pulakesin II - tells that all minor and major events were recorded - but no such archive found - tells that he divided his time into three parts → 1 part for administration → 2 parts for religious activities - nobody else mentioned - mentioned he made large no of monasteries - no archaeological evidence found
Accounts of Banabhatta from Harshacharita and Kadambari
- mentions empire was extensive and consisted of five Indies - actually, only five parts of North India - mentions that Harsha made elaborate preparations to occupy Gauda - doesn't mention outcome - records suggest Shashanka ruled upto around 636 AD - doesn't mention about Harsha's defeat in hands of Pulakesin II - known only from Aihole inscription of Ravikirti
It can be noticed that although Harsha was great but has been made greater by Bana and Yuan Chiang (Hieun Tsang) which can be seen from few limitations - inability to wipe out feudal lords - empire collapsed after his death - couldn't check economic decline - lost battle with Chalukyas - negligible developments in art and culture