Topper Copies

How far do you agree that the Mughal State was centralized State? Discuss.

Nausheen, AIR 9, 2023

Mughal state was established by Babur after Battle of Panipat against Ibrahim Lodhi. From then on and mostly till the time of Aurangzeb the State was largely centralised but there is a debate among historians about the extent of this centralisation.

1. Prof. Irfan Habib argues that Mughal state was highly centralised politically. This political centralisation promoted social and economic centralisation too. He argues that this centralisation was based on State structures like centralised bureaucracy (Mansabdari system), jagirdari system, Royal karkhanas etc. 2. Similarly, Stephen Blake argues that Mughal was a centralised State in the form of patrimonial bureaucracy. Patriarch is the head of house and when the influence of patriarch extends to whole state it takes the form of patrimonial bureaucracy. - This proposition has been criticised by historians like Satish Chandra who argues that the state was patrimonial bureaucratic state only in the initial years and not later. 3. Athar Ali has cited cultural reasons for the centralisation which are idea of farr-i-izadi, sulh-i-kul etc.

The theory of centralisation has come under severe criticisms. 1. MN Pearson argues that the Mughal state was not centralised even during the most powerful rule of Akbar, Jahangir and Shah Jahan. - The jagir system was not very controlled centrally and the transfers were also not very frequent.

Also there were some amount of local independence.

To believe that Mughal state was not centralised helps us argue against the fact that the political decline in 18th c brought economic and social decline (Dark Age). The weak centralisation proposition proves that the regions like Bengal, Gujarat, Agra, Lucknow were flourishing then under local rule.