Topper Copies

To what extent can Germany be held responsible for causing the two World Wars? Discuss critically.

Nausheen, AIR 9, 2023

Germany was held responsible for two world wars by some sections of historians. However, This is a limited understanding on the cause of war and lot of other phenomenon can be held responsible for it.

1. Germany held responsible.

(i) The Paris Peace Conference - (a) The "war guilt" clause of the Treaty of Versailles held Germany solely responsible for war. - (b) All actions were mainly directed against Germany. For e.g. - (i) Taking away colonies and putting under mandates system. - (ii) Reducing strength of army. - (iii) Taking away coal rich region (saar).

1.(ii) Fischer's Theisis - (a) After World War II, Louis Fischer - with help from German official papers tried to show that Germany's foreign policy being guided by "Labenstraum" & resulted in war. - (b) They deliberately allowed events to slide into a big blown war.

However, historians, now, generally take a balanced understanding of the causes of war.

Causes of World War I

1. (i) Role of Nationalism → nations were driven by intense nationalism and wanted to win the war at any cost. - (ii) Role of National humiliation - (a) Germany's demand was not accepted in Algiers' Conference. - (b) Russia and Serbia humiliated with Austrian takeover of Bosnia. - (c) French had to give Congo in 1911. - (iii) Role of Arms Race. - (a) Neills Fergusson argues that arms race [?] in Europe in preceding century created a suspicion in powers. - (iv) Role of Newspaper & Press. - (a) They played a huge role in highlighting and popularising the cause. - (v) Role of Faction building - (a) Formation of Entente cordiale in 1904 and Triple Entente in 1907 led to growing suspicion.

Causes of World War II

1. Policy of Appeasement followed by Britain and France. - (a) reducing war reparations - (b) no action on Germany conquering Rhineland and Czechoslovakia . 2. Failure of League of Nations - (a) Couldn't stop German agression in east. 3. Role of Treaty of Versailles. - (a) flawed notion of taking revenge from Germany. - (b) Helped fuel hyper nationalism in Germany. 4. Role of Locarno Pact - (a) It did not guarantee Germany's eastern frontier. - (b) The conquest of Poland by Germany resulted in response from Germany and France.

Historians like G. Ritter, Bernard Fay, Neils Fergusson Taylor thus do not now hold Germany as being responsible for war.