"The establishment of British rule led to the complete ruining of traditional industries (handicrafts) in India." Critically examine.
Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024
Early Indian critiques of colonialism has put forth the thesis of deindustrialization of handicrafts in India by the British coupled with "drain of wealth" theory of Naroji.
Ruining of Traditional industries =>
1. The British applied be unequal trade duties so export of handicrafts became expensive 2. Cheap imports from Europe flooded the Indian markets. 3. RC.Dutt has observed that the artisans were persuaded, sometimes through oppression to give up their trade secrets. 4. Naroji has estimated that every 3rd rupee generated in India went to England to fill their coffers. 5. British historian Colin Clarke had estimated that workers employed in manufacturing sector in India reduced from 37% in 1881 to less than 17%. in 1913. 6. R.C. Dutt and MG Ranade also stated that the British system worked in such a way, it evaporated moisture from ganges and would rain it in Thames. 7. Karl Marx accused British colonizers for ruining weaving and spinning industries, Charkhe, in India.
However, the view in recent times have been contested by the Revisionist historians.
1. Tirthankar Roy had pointed out that though British coffers increased from Indian revenue, Indians also gained. He said that overall per capita income of manufacturers increased. 2. Morris D Morris had observed that there was a worldwide phenomenon of deindustrialization of the crafts due to advent of modern machines. He also stated that export from India to Britain was not more than 2%. 3. Rajat Ray had observed that rich were becoming richer but by no means, poors were becoming poorer.
Most historians have however agreed that the rich industries, handlooms and crafts of India recieved a setback after the British advent.