"The federal part of the 1935 act remained a non-starter, as no one seemed to be really interested in it." Comment.
Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024
The 'Government of India Act 1935' had clearly demarcated the federal and the provincial powers of the govt to be formed under the act.
However, the federal powers remained a non starter because =>
1. The Princes did not sent their nominees. Moreover INC too wanted it to be democratic. 2. The British were continuing to rule having majority in the legislative council and thus Indians were not interested and against this domination. 3. The budgetary powers were still not allowed explicitly to Indians. 4. Elections indirect at central level and thus INC was dissatisfied. 5. Moreover veto power by the governor over everything killed the purpose of self govt.
This had made Pt Nehru say that we demanded an engine and what we have got are only brakes. However, so to use the opportunity and avoid the British to pass laws arbitarily at provincial levels, INC decided to assume office and gain experience at working at the political level and staying connected to ground as well. Gandhiji thus said that "accept the office but treat them as the "crown of thorns"" Thus though federal part remained a non starter, provincial part could be utilized for welfare of peasants, working men, businessmen, students etc.