"The social base of the early Congress was unmistakably narrow. It had uneven representation and total exclusion of non-elite groups of Indian society." Critically analyse.
Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024
Early base of Indian National Congress comprised of educated and well aware Indian middle class, who wanted a platform where they can put their political demands before British.
Social base has been very narrow for the early congress as -
1. Only 72 delegates in first meeting, and mostly lawyers, upper caste Brahmins, mostly Hindus (exception - Badruddin Tayabji). 2. Even by 1889, 6000 delgates were there but constituted only 44 cultivators and only 10 artisans from lower castes. 3. Women representation was meagre 4. Speeches in English were given, detached from masses. 5. Mass issues were not brought up. 6. Dalit representation was also negligible - something Dr Ambedkar protested against at a later date.
Exclusion of non elite groups was not only confined to presence but also issues ->
1. Delegates were largely loyalists of the empire. WC Bonerjie said we do not want a nest of conspirators here. 2. Passive criticism of govt policy. 3. Worker rights demanded but only on plantations where British were owners not in Indian owned industries.
Sumit Sarkar said that the aim of Congress was totally detached from the masses who were not brought into politics before advent of Gandhi.
Gokhale justified early INC agenda by stating these steps were important for our nation as this type of politics was totally new to this land.