"... instead of rejecting the Cabinet Mission Plan, the Congress Leadership resorted to a half-baked legalistic stratagem to reserve their position on its long-term arrangements and accepted its short-term provisions." Explain.
Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024
Although Cabinet Mission planheed several "seperatist tendencies" in its inherent nature, it was treated by Congress as a short term arrangement to reserve their position
Provisions of Cabinet Mission ->
1. It divided the nation into groups A, B, C, D and states were kept in them for seperate governance based & largely on religion. 2. There was a provincial autonomy given to states, thus it was a loosely federal arrangement- 3. Centre only had few important roles namely - defense, communication and foreign affairs. 4. Meanwhile all parties were asked to send their representatives to sit at Central legislature. 5. Constituent Assembly was to be formed by these members and provisions to be drafted with due discussion.
Congress accepted these provisions because ⇒
1. Immediately partition can be avoided for time being. 2. Constituent Assembly will be drafted with mutual consent. 3. Communal harmony can be ensured meanwhile. 4. Provinces can be appeased.
However, later Jinnah rejected and started Direct Action Day leading to riots, ultimately ending Mountbatten Plan.