Q.4 (b) "Doubtless it was not a free state; it was any rate a state" (K A N Sastri). Reflect upon the nature of local self government institutions in the Chola kingdom.
Nausheen, AIR 9, 2023
Local self government in the chola kingdom is cited as an example of early democracy in india by Nationalist historians. Also, an attempt to establish local self government. However, they were not as independent as they are made to be.
Doubtless it was not a free state. 1. The assemblies (ur, sabha and nagarams) were independent in their functioning but the chola king could direct them for fulfilling certain duties. For e.g. collection of revenue for state. 2. Two inscriptions are reflective of the dependence on the king of these assemblies:- - Uttaramerur Inscription tells that selection of officials in committee of sabha was made in the presence of Chola officials. - Thanjavur Inscription :- They were made to administer Kanchipuram temple at behalf of Chola dynasty. 3. 'Taniyur' status was given to 'sabha assemblies' by the king. 4. The regions of Kaveri river basin was under direct control over the state while far flung areas were granted slight independence.
However, it was any rate a state. 1. System of elections to the committee of assemblies. - 'lot' system - bundling of 12 streets into wards & the members of committee thus were selected by drawing a vote. - All members (elders) of the village used to participate in the election process. 2. System of qualification and disqualification of members. 3. Constitution of committees in these assemblies (variyams). For e.g. Tank Committee, Garden Committee, Gold Committee → to look after various aspects of administration. 4. System of financial scrutiny by 'accountants' in the villages.
However, there were certain shortcomings in the nature of state :- - (i) No system of quorum - (ii) Qualification of elections such as knowledge of abrahmanya, 1 veda ensured only brahmans were granted seats. - (iii) Property qualifications for running elections
Thus, local assemblies of cholas can be considered "state with its limitations" but certainly was an attempt of establishing democracy in the kingdom.