Q.1 (b) How far do you agree with the statement that the Caliphate was the source and sanction of the legal authority of the Delhi Sultans.
Nausheen, AIR 9, 2023
The system of Caliphate began after the death of Prophet Muhammad, the founder of Islam. The Caliph used to be the religious head of the muslim world and also the political head.
No ruler in Muslims was independent and legitimised until they seek sanction in the forms of letter of investitute from him.
Other methods used by Delhi Sultans were:- 1. Inscribing his name on coins being circulated in the kingdom. 2. Grant of robe. 3. Reading his name on khutba during Friday prayers.
For e.g. - Iltutmish inscribed the name of caliph on his coins.
However, this was considered more of a nominal allegiance to seek legitimacy to the rule of Sultans.
This is clear from the facts that:- 1. No Sultan was removed from his position upon failing to seek sanction / letter of investiture. 2. Sultans who had stronghold over their kingdom did not even seeked such nominal legitimacy.
For e.g.. - Alauddin Khalji - did not receive 'manshur' - letter of investiture and called himself deputy of Caliph. - Mubarak Khalji - called himself the Caliph.
However, when rulers were weak in their authority; they sought caliph recognition to save themselves from revolt / opposition.
For e.g.. - Mohammad bin Tughlaq → to deal with his waning prestige. - Firuz Tughlaq.
Thus, it was not compulsory for Delhi Sultans to seek sanction from caliph and thus, the State was not a theocratic state