"SR Bommai vs Union..." signified a paradigm shift in judicial interpretation of union's authority to assume control of State's admin". Discuss significance and impact of the judgement in cementing federal structure.
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
SR Bommai case is a landmark federalism case, which has significantly advanced the spirit of federalism in the country.
The judgement was related to imposition of President's rule, and dismissal of SR Bommai as Karnataka CM in 1989, on ground of not having absolute majority, post election.
Significance of the judgement in cementing federal structure 1. Federalism declared to be part of Basic Structure Doctrine 2. SC gave clear guidelines for imposition of President's rule under Article 356 - objectively, there must be materials/documents on the basis of which it has been decided that "governance cannot be in accordance with constitution" 3. Lack of absolute majority post elections is not one such ground 4. Courts can look into advice/documents/reports/materials on the basis of which Union Council of Ministers advises President to impose Article 356 5. Imposition of Article 356 is subject to judicial review 6. Governor is not to dissolve the Assembly before getting legislative approval from Parliament (60 days according to Article 356) - till approval, Assembly is only to be suspended 7. If courts find action to be malafide, courts have power to revive the Assembly 8. Floor test to be used for deciding confidence 9. Article 356 may violate federalism, hence, it is to be used sparingly; it was intended to be a "dead letter" 10. SC also held that [the sentence stops here in the original, left unfinished]
Impact of the judgement 1. Incidents of the use of Article 356 have reduced drastically. 2. Used only ~30 times in past 30 years since the judgement (compared to 80+ times in the first 40 years of independence, before the judgement) 3. Supremacy of floor test: upheld in Jagdambika Pal vs State of UP 4. Significant interpretation of constitution - while courts can't look into advice rendered to President, they may look into material on basis of which advice was tendered 5. Power to judiciary to reinstate assembly - prevents hasty decision by Governor
Dr. Ambedkar intended it to be a "dead letter". Hence SR Bommai judgement has gone a long way in institutionalizing spirit of constitution Assembly.