"The importance of the Crimean War should be measured not by its immediate tangible results but by the most important political developments to which it was a prelude." Critically examine. [20 Marks]
Nausheen, AIR 9, 2023
"Crimean War is the most useless war of European history". The above statement highlights the gloom surrounding the causes and consequences of war of Crimea.
MEASURED NOT BY IMMEDIATE TANGIBLE RESULTS.
1. Cause of War and outcome
1. Main cause was mainly religious issue. - Russia: wanted to protect Slavs subjects due to racial connect with them. - France: wanted to protect to gain its "lost prestige". - to protect Roman Catholic subjects. - Britain: wanted to save its eastern colonies from dominance of Russia. - Austria: wanted "free and open" Adriatic Sea.
All these causes were fulfilled only for limited time as :- - France lost its prestige soon in Battle of Sedan. - Russia conquered Bessarabia and started Thereatening Austrian trade.
2. "Sick Man of Europe" → Turkey.
- It was brought on its "legs" but the dissolution was soon brought due to WWI.
Thus, Crimean war was without any tangible results. However, had important political developments as consequence :-
1. German Unification. - Prussia - Russia alliance emerged. - Russia turned away from Austria which remained neutral during Crimean war despite Russian support to it during Polish Hungarian revolt (1848-49). 2. Italian Unification - Cavour used his masterful diplomacy to highlight the rise of Italian unification. - Secured neutrality of Britain and France by sending troops to support the cause of war. 3. Reforms in Russia - The defeat in war of Russia, propled the king to initiate reforms like emancipation of serfs. 4. Nationalism - Fostered nationalism in various cultural groups in the region => eventually led to disintegration of Ottoman empire. - causes of WWI also lie in this.
Thus, Crimean war was 'useless' in immediate consequences but brought changes that governed the upcoming century.