How did the Permanent Settlement initiate a rule of property in Bengal? What were its consequences? [20 Marks]
Ashish Raghuwanshi
Cornwallis introduced Permanent Settlement in Bengal in 1793 which was made with Zamindars.
Initiated a Rule of property in Bengal
1. Settlement made with Zamindars and every piece of land in Bengal became part of Zamindari or estate. 2. Property rights of zamindars recognized who could sell, mortgage, transfer his property. 3. This was done so that zamindars would invest in lands as benefits from increased income will come to them. Land Revenue fixed permanently at 10/11th of produce. 4. If the zamindars, fails to pay the revenue on time, his land would be auctioned and all property rights shifted to new owner.
This was creation of private property in Bengal.
However Daniel Thorner writes creation of private property was 'Misnomer' - Absolute ownership was with imperial authority. - Sun-set law- if revenue not paid before time, then auction & their were various sales & dispossessions in Bengal.
Consequences
1. On Agriculture => Ruination. Over assessment was common feature leading to high revenue demand. As there was fear of dispossession and after such high payments, zamindars were left with little to invest. 2. On Peasants - reduced to "tenant at will" - patta system not respected - high rents - loans from moneylenders which led to indebtedness 3. On zamindars - from Revenue collector to owner of Land - However, "Sunset clause" -> widespread sales. - However, many of these lands bought by zamindars' own amlas and relatives. - land was parcelled among each oth[?] (e.g.-> Burdwan Raj. 4. New Social classes Rajat and Ratnalekha Ray writes a powerful Jotedar- Haoladar class came to prominence and Zamindars didn't have actual occupancy rights. 5. Exploitation - by zamindar-daroga nexus, zamindars extracted abwabs, etc.
Hence, British rule led to private property in India but the dislocations brought in countryside led to series of agrarian uprisings against British in 18th century and 19th century.