For long, the Revolt of 1857, has been mistaken to be a mere mutiny of the Indian sepoys in the Bengal army. However, its causes need to be searched for not only in the dissatisfaction of the army, but in a long drawn process of fundamental social and economic change that upset the peasant communities. Discuss. [20 Marks]
Ashish Raghuwanshi
The Revolt of 1857 was a popular military and civilian uprising against the rule of. British East India Company (EIC).
- British administrators described it as Mere 'mutiny', narrative carried on by imperialist historians. However, Karl Marx wrote in New York Daily Post, what is labelled as Mutiny is actually a national revolt. - VD Sawarkar called it war fought "Swaraj" and "Swadharma" - RC Mazumdar writes what began as a popular uprising a mutiny became a civil population joined. as
Therefore, its causes are multiple.
Dissatisfaction of Army
1. Service related grievances - racism in promotion. 2. The privileges which were given to high caste army such as extra allowance were done away with. 3. Uniform military culture promoted in 1830s hurt the traditions. 4. Religious grievance - Fear of conversions - e.g Rumours of pig and cow bone dust in flour. 5. Grievances at home as soldiers were after all peasents in uniform.
Immediate Cause : Rumours that the new Enfield Rifle has grease made of pig and cow fat which needs to be bitten off before loading.
However, causes needs to be searched also in long drawn process of fundamental social and economic changes :-
1. Common belive that British rule immoral and aim to christianize. e.g. Lex Loci Act. 2. Political annexations e.g. Doctrine of Lapse. Awadh annexed on ground of Maladministration. Deposed feudal lords like Rani Jhansi, Nana Saheb became leaders. 3. Ruination of Countryside - There were high Revenue demand, Summary settlement, exploitation by Moneylenders, indebtedness, landlessness in Zamindari, Ryotwari, Mahalwari 4. Deindustrialisation and dislocation of traditional industries. - Amiya Kumar Bagchi -> 18 % in 1890 to 8 % in 1901 -> population depended on Secondary activities. - Therefore, artisans disatisfied. 5. Social reforms brought despite resistance (e.g. Sati Abolition, widow Remarriage, etc 6. pre-history of peasant and tribal uprising and brutal repression. 7. Common Feeling among Hindus and Muslims that religion under threat.
Hence, Began as military mutiny, due to various grievances different Sections joined and as highlighted by Rudrangshu Mukherjee it was Major jolt to mighty British Raj.