Topper Copies

Critically examine the account of Alberuni of the Indian society.

Dharani M, AIR 250, 2023

Alberuni, a persian scholar from khawarezm empire came to India along with malmud Ghazni and was fascinated by the Indian conditions, he wrote an account in Arabic known as "KITAB - UL - HIND".

AL-BERUNI's Account of Indian Society

1. The caste system

Al Biruni mentions about the chaturvarna system and purusha shukta's classification of humans into Brahmins, Kshatriyas and vaishyas.

[a sketch map of north-west and north India with Kashmir, Varanasi and the Ghaznavid empire marked]

He describes about a section of people called ANTYAJA who did crafts occupation other than the one mentioned in the chaturvarna system. Last class is the untouchables who were outcastes doing menial things and they were illegitimate children. 2. The isolationary nature of Indian society coupled with superiority attitude

"The Indians believed that there is no country like theirs, no king like theirs, no religion like theirs and no science like theirs" 3. He also talks about the social evils that is prevalent in the society like child marriage, sati, illtreatment of women, widows in particular. 4. Insulatory attitude and society and non sharing of knowledge by the Brahmins with any person outside their caste, outside their religion, even within their caste and definetly not to a foreigner. 5. He talks about the religious practices & Beliefs he tells that multitude of gods is vulgar and is the attitude of the uneducated.

He also talks about patanjali, Samkhya and puranas and gita. where they mention about moksha as something - highof knowledge attainment. Educated people consider god as someone without beginning and an end. 6. He talks about social customs and he talks about dressing habits where men wore trousers and turbans and even some female articles of clothing.

They have red teeth due to usage of arecanut, betel leaves and chalk They had long mustaches in single plait, long nails as a testament to their idleness 7. He even talks about Indian festivals like Chaitra, Guru pitiya etc.. He also talks about the concept of moksha, vishnupurana's paradise and hell - Nagaraloka, patala concept.

Limitations on Alberuni's Examination of Indian society

1. Language Barrier:

Though he learnt sanskrit language, there were numerous other Languages in use 2. Differences in the religious beliefs and peactices did not enable him to appreciate things fully 3. The insularity and self absorption of the local population had been an impediment. 4. He read many literature but interpretation may have been different in many cases. 5. His information was not based on nonsanskrit texts he relied solely on sanskrit literature 6. Even-though he knew abt varahamihira and Aryabhatta, he chose to generalise Indian's were backward in science — this seems a biased view.

Thus though it has its Limitations Alberuni's Kitab ul Hind seems to be a very important Source of the early medieval Indian period.