Topper Copies

FRs are not gifts bestowed upon by the state, rather an individual possesses them independent of the state. In this context, discuss desirability of reasonable restrictions on various FRs.

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

The given statement relates to the relationship between natural rights, fundamental rights, reasonable restrictions, and the social contract.

- Fundamental rights: guaranteed to all citizens; enforceable against the state; key to basic human existence (civil and political) - Natural rights: universal; not dependent on any state/culture, etc. - Reasonable restrictions: restrictions to FRs - Social contract: agreement of man - which results in society

"Fundamental rights and reasonable restrictions are a means to balance natural rights and the social contract"

FRs are not gifts imposed by state 1. Man are born equal, equality is not given by state 2. Hence, Article 14: "State shall not deny to any person equality before law or equal protection of laws" → "State shall not deny" means State is not the origin of this fundamental right 3. Similarly, Article 21: "No person's life or personal liberty shall be taken away unless by procedure established by law" → "shall not be taken away" means State is not the origin of this right → State's role is to ensure this right is NOT TAKEN AWAY

Yet, certain FRs are bestowed by the state 1. Article 16: equality of opportunity in public employment → public employment is under ambit of sovereignty of State → if state so desires, it needn't ensure equality of opportunity in public employment 2. Similarly, for Articles 29, 30, and so on

Desirability of reasonable restrictions, to ensure the social contract 1. In rights bestowed by state - reasonable restrictions are the will of the state. 2. Even in natural rights, reasonable restrictions help ensure constitutionalism: - Sovereignty and integrity of India: necessary for sanctity of state - Public order and morality: for social morality, part of the social contract; for law and order, necessary to ensure other citizens may enjoy their rights - India's interests with foreign nations: to protect sovereignty - "Interests of scheduled areas": to preserve rights of indigenous communities - For public health: to prevent faith from harming citizens - To give effect to socio-economic rights via DPSPs - (eg.) Aadhaar as violation of privacy, for public service delivery

Hence, reasonable restrictions must exist: "India is a land of no absolutes"

However, if fundamental rights are violated, Doctrine of Proportionality must be used, with Harmonious Construction.