Topper Copies

“With the best intentions, excellent ideas, but no balance or patience, no sense of proportion, Muhammad Tughluq was a transcendent failure”. Elaborate.

Dharani M, AIR 250, 2023

Muhammad Bin Tughlaq ruled the Delhi Sultanate empire from 1325 when he succeeded his father Ghiyassudhin Tughluq to 1351 when he died. In mean time, he has done many good ideas which then turned on to fail miserably.

The Best Intentions and excellent ideas which then Failed because of impropoption & imbalance & Impatientness of muhammad Bin Tughlaq

1. Excellent ideas & Intentions of Muhammad Bin Tughlaq

Military reforms * Repeated mongol invasion and more Concentration of south India rather than multan and north west from Alauddhin Khilji times.

The tabarhind Tarmashirin invasion accentuated the need for northwest protection

Agrarian reforms * Both required huge Army, so he vigorously Collected land revenue, more tax newcesses and old revenue like Ghorai, Chacai, khaai etc.

More strict revenue collection which then accentuated by Famine, made peasants revolt

IDEA -> Agrarian reforms. -> Increase production -> Crop rotation Barley -> wheat crop pattern change wheat -> Sugarcane Sugarcane -> Grapes & Fruits "Barani says 70 lakh tanka as Loans" "Afif says 2 koor tankas" -> SONDHAR LOANS To buy seeds, implements, dig wells. * wafa-i-Farmani Nikha-i-Farmani taxes. -> DIWAN-I-AMIR-I-KOHI. Increase Land area of Agriculture.

Economic reforms * To again improve revenue earned from trade and commerce and to improve trade since there was silver, gold shortage, he introduced TOKEN currency in copper & Bronze

IDEA -> TOKEN currency

It had persian and Arabic inscriptions on them.

Administrative reforms * Since Delhi sultanate spanned over a big portion in north & south he decided to shift

IDEA -> people from Delhi To Deogiri (Daulatabad) to better administ[?] Sultanate in 1329.

[a sketch map of India marking Peshawar, Multan, Khurasan expedition, Qarachil expedition, Sindh, Delhi, and the shift from Delhi to Daulatabad, captioned "fig① MBT - Ideas & Expedition"]

Impatience, Imbalance & misproportion leading to failure of above ideas .....

IDEAS Reason for Failure

1. Qarachil Expedition

[a sketch map of Kashmir with arrows through the Himalaya towards W. Tibet, marked rain and disease]

Khusrau malik though had early victory didnt listen when ordered to come back, he furthered north, stuck in rain, disease in w.Tibet many soldiers perished ↓ Huge loss of soldiers, money Respect

2. Agrarian reforms

it failed due to . 1. Impatient implementation 2. wrong choice of land for the project 3. No enthusiasm among farmers. 4. No effective monitoring by Bureaucracy .

3. Rigorous collection of wafa-i-Farmani and nikha-i-Farmani — Impoverished the peasantry resulting in rebellion leading to withdrawal of sondhar reforms within three years.

3. Economic reforms

According to Barani, Qublai Khan did it for almost 1261-1294 (33 years) in china. But in Delhi sultanate, that continued for 3 yrs

The inadequate preparation and misunderstanding abt local peoples ability to understand & differentiate persian & Arabic versus led to Failure Even Barani tells about every hindu household turning into a mint. menace of forged coins made him to exchange all copper & Brass token coins for silver.

4. Administrative reforms

The exodus to Deogiri 1. Homesickness of the people who lived in Delhi for more than 100yrs 2. The improper timing - SUMMER SEASON and famine made many people die of exhausion

5. The overambitious Khurasan experiment and subsequent disbanding of 3.7Lakh soldiers led to rebellion and subsequent hollowing of prestige of muhammad bin Tughlaq.

Though these schemes were disbanded, they were excellent Ideas when done properly it would have fetched returns Muhammad Bin Tughlaq was thinking far beyond his time and required the skill to implement efficiently .