Q.3 (b) "On circumstantial evidence Indra stands accused." Discuss the given statement in the context of the decline of Harappan Civilisation.
Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024
A civilization as extensive as that of Harappan civilization certainly takes a lot to decline. The decline must have been a long process as well as should be a result of more than one factors as pointed out by most historians.-
One group of historians however believe that the chief cause of the decline of Harappan civilization was the Aryan Invasion. This view is held by Mortimer Wheeler, Romila Thapar and others.
1. In the Rig vedas, there is mentioned a year which was won by 'Purandar' or 'Indra' where he stormed in the fortress. The fortress here is interpreted as the fort of Mohenjodaro attacked by Indra as an Aryan invasion 2. Rig veda also mentions a city named 'Hariyupiya' which has bee[n] identified by historians as Harappa 3. On analysing the skeleton remains and other archeological evidence, they conclude that it the decline was a result of nothing other than an invasion from north.
However the facts according to other group of historians are not enough to establish an Aryan invasion theory as ⇒ 1. The Harappan cities and towns declined by 1800 BCE and Aryans came by 1500 BCE. So there was quite some gap. 2. Moreover Skeleton remains found depicts that their death happened neither at same place nor at around same time thus discrediting the theory of massacre.
Historians have pointed out other factors for the decline of Harappan civilization. 1. Prof. Shireen Ratnagar believes that the decline happened due to the collapse of trade and commerce between Harappan and Mesopotamian civilization. 2. Prof. Irfan Habib had cited political reasons as responsible. when the ruling community failed to gain taxes, the empire collapsed. 3. W.A. Fairservice points that it was due to overgrazing and overexploitation that the land got exploited and leading to decline in agriculture and surplus. 4. Many historians also believe that it was due to repeated floods that the decline happened.
Thus going by few literary evidences, 'Indra' stands accused of the decline. However, digging the causes seem even more deeper, the causes seem even more significant than the decline itself.