Topper Copies

Q.2 (c) What were the factors responsible for the rise and decline of the republics (Ganas or Sanghas) during the time of Gautam Buddha? Were they democratic in nature?

Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024

The existence of Republics or ganas / Sanghas in the ancient India is often hailed by historians against the idea of Vincent Smith that India has seen nothing but despotism in its history.

The republics were a particular feature of early India were the people were organized in groups headed by more than one chief. All of them were called 'Rajas'.

The factors behind the rise of Ganas and sanghas are ⇒

1. In the post vedic period, when agriculture and crafts became prominent, the people organized themselves into groups for better productivity. Thus particular societies were often associated with specific beasts. 2. Society was stratified at that time and there were constant attacks from the enemies of different areas. Therefor the powerful men of the communities together used to take charge of protecting people who came to be called rajas. 3. These ganas were better suited for people than orthodox kingdoms, more rigid like in later vedic period. 4. Republics were religiously and professionally more liberal granting people full autonomy. No Brahman [?] dominance. Eg. Vrishnis, lichhavis etc.

However these ganas could not last long and soon they declined. Main factors for their decline ⇒ 1. Gradual rise in urbanization and development leading to more compacted society paving way for monarchies. 2. Discovery and use in wide scale of iron implements helped in consolidation of empires. 3. Personal aimbition of few individuals. 4. Even some autocratic elements began to creep in ganas. 5. If one gana turned monarchy, others had to in order to defend themselves

It has often been questioned whether ganas were democratic in nature. Well it is agreed by historians that they were not the democracies in modern sense. Still they had some democratic features - 1. People's role in making decisions. 2. People collectively deciding most powerful among them as rajah. 3. More than one rajah, signifying distribution of power. 4. Voluntary taxation against oppressive one in monarchies later. 5. Freedom of religion and occupation.

Thus despite not being true democracy, they had certain liberal elements, ahead of its times that made them stand out.