Critics assert that limitless judicial authority rests on structural ambiguity of BSD. Has the elastic nature of Basic structure made judiciary more powerful than executive?
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
The Basic Structure Doctrine was originated in the Kesavananda Bharati case (1973), and relates to the amending power of Parliament.
The doctrine asserts that Parliament has unlimited amending power, as long as it does not violate/abridge/contravene the Basic Structure.
The basic structure is an "idea in the minds of the judges" - uncodified. Over the years, via various judgements, it has come to include:
i.e, if in a future case, SC thinks that something needs to be added to Basic Structure, it can add the same, to further limit the Parliament.
Critics allege that limitless judicial authority rests on structural ambiguity of BSD 1. Uncodified nature 2. Constitutional silences: something which the constitution is silent on, and yet imposes restrictions on govt action, if against essential facets of constitution. 3. BSD is one of the "constitutional silences" in India (other being "constitutional morality") 4. Both are in hands of judiciary. 5. It may lead to judicial overreach. 6. It is referred to as "tyranny of the unelected" (as Executive is accountable to the legislature, but not the judiciary) 7. Potential violation of separation of powers - as law-making is domain of legislature 8. "Constitutional confusion" - via PILs. (eg.) People have begun to routinely approach courts for policy matters. 9. "Intra-constitutional hierarchy"
On the other hand, judiciary has used Basic Structure sparingly 1. Used only 19 times in ~50 years 2. Used mostly in cases of blanket violation of spirit of constitution. (eg.) "unlimited amendment powers", "no judicial review" - both from the 42nd Amendment 3. Constitutional amendments have been invalidated only on one ground - judicial independence (judicial review)
Way forward 1. Codification of basic structure - as done in Germany. 2. Merging of all "constitutional silences" into one: Basic Structure and Constitutional Morality should not be separately used to strike down laws. This will lead to greater mistrust and confusion.
Foundation of constitutionalism is a state limited by constitution. Basic Structure represents more limitations ⇒ hence must be codified.