Q.4 (b) How far do you agree that the Mughal State was centralized State? Discuss.
Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024
Western historians like Vincent Smith from the beginning had believed India as always dominated and ruled by autocratic depots. In fact many believe Mughal state to a theocratic one. However the reality today seems different.
Prof. Irfan Habib and Satish Chandra believes that Mughal state was not a theocratic state in terms of large scale religious conversions. However they agree that it was a highly centralized state. This centralization is meant in terms of =>
1. Centralized bureaucracy. 2. centralized and uniform land revenue administration. 3. Centralized political authority. 4. Enlightened despotism.
Thus they believed that the centralization was in terms of uniformity in empire. This view had been held by Athar Ali.
However revisionist historians like Muzaffar Alam, Sanjay Subramanyam and Chetan Singh has challenged this view citing that on studying in detail the land revenue systems in Awadh and Punjab, it is clear that Mughal state was not a uniformly centralized state. The economy of the empire had been customized according to the local conditions eg. Todar Mal planned land systems of Bengal as per the provincial needs.
Moreover, local peasantry's state also varied from place to place.
This centralization that was at its peak during Akbar began to weaken during his successors. Many mansabdars began to extract revenue independently not in accordance with laid guidelines. This very phenomenon has roughly been called as 'Jagirdari crises', that began in the reign of Aurangzeb and completed the after him leading to the decline of Mughal empire.
Thus the Mughal empire was centralized politically to a great extent under the leadership of Delhi emperor. However, economy varied from place to place. Also the bureaucracy was different during different emperors. whereas it was well organized during Akbar, under Jahangir and Shahjahan, the mansabdari system began to weaken with officers failing to bring required contingents.
So Mughal empire was which definitely seemed an homogeneous whole had inherent heterogeneity which was gradually evident.