Topper Copies

"The importance of the Crimean War should be measured not by its immediate tangible results but by the most important political developments to which it was a prelude." Critically examine.

Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024

Historian Robert Morier has refered the Crimean war as one of the most unnecessary battles ever fought in history. This is because of its excessive wastage of life and property as well as because of its futile and rather negative long term results.

Immediate results of Crimean war were little. It was fought when Russia attacked Ottoman Empire which was then defended by Britain and France who attacked Russia.

Short term tangible results => 1. Treaty of Paris was signed where the occupied territories were restored. This ensured peace immediately. 2. Ottomans promised to respect religious rights which though looked promising immediately but was not followed 3. All the powers agreed to use the straits collectively. Black sea should be remained open for all in war as well as peace. 4. Turkish straits would be used by all in peace time and in war time, only by allies of sultan.

These 8 clauses looked promising to the leaders who thought the peace had been established. This was a grave mistake as it was the beginning of all the power-tussel..

The long term political developments that the war caused were grave in nature => 1. Russian aimbitions did not stop and it again attacked Turkey in 1878 ending in Treaty of San Stefano. 2. Other powers, in order to curb Russian aimbitions gathered in 1883 at Berlin and Treaty of Berlin was signed, moderated by Bismarck where Russia lost all it gained and was embittered : 3. Germany kept growing closer to Austria and Russia felt embittered and began signing alliances with nations like France. 4. The question of the Eastern Europe, popularly called 'Eastern Question' remained unresolved as slavs of Serbia, Bosnia Herzegovina, Romania, Greece, Russia wanted to unite. Ottoman empire committed infact hostilities on slav minority which embittered Balkan nations. Thus Berlin conference could not resolve the issue.

Balkan peninsula remained a troubled one, Ottoman empire came to be known as 'sick man of Europe', the European powers continued looking for own selfish interests and war momentum continued to build up. Thus finally ended with the outbreak of first world war as a result of secret alliance system.