Topper Copies

"The hypothesis that there was urban decay during c. 300-600 CE is questionable on several grounds." Comment. [15 Marks]

Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024

The period from 200 BCE - 300 CE is considered as a high watermark of cultural and economic prosperity of Indian subcontinent. However it is believed by many that it was followed by a gloomy period from 300 - 600 CE.

Prof. R.S. Sharma and D.D. Kosambi has coined the theory of urban decay. They propounded that these centuries saw decline in urbanization and shift to feudalization, agriculture and thus ruralization. Prof. Sharma had substantiated his theory of urban decay citing evidences =>

1. The period from 300 - 600 CE has revealed almost a drastic decline in the number of coins. Impact in the Gupta period had seen lesser number of coins than Kushana period. 2. There are more evidences of land grants to Brahmanas which signifies that feudalism began to emerge. 3. Sharma propounded that the 'Kali yuga crisis' mentioned in Puranas has been referred to the phenomenon where the Brahmin Kshatriya dominance was challenged by vaisyas and sudras. Thus former began to grab as much land as possible to reduce the latter to destitute. 4. This can be substantiated by the fact that position of women sudras and vaisyas declined in post Gupta period. 5. Also architectural and literary sources mention meagre evidences of urban towns with mostly rural descriptions which points towards urban decay

This theory has been put to question by many historians. Y.S. Subbarayalu believes that at any point of time in history, not more than 20% of land was granted to Brahmana thus Kali age crisis theory is not justified. He also mentions that there are ample evidences that not all the cities and towns declined. Subbarayalu stated that south Indian cities like Madurai, Thanjavur, Aihole etc flourished under regional rulers in this period as evident from texts. Thus despite maximum land grants in south, there wasnt an urban decay. Moreover, in Bengal also, ports continued to flourish like Tamralipti

Therefore historians to great extent agrees that despite a slow-down in economic urban activity in the said period, there was not a blanket urban decay. Also the decline in urbanization was not uniform throughout the subcontinent.