Topper Copies

How has anti-defection law impacted relationship between pol parties and individual legislators? In light of recent incidents, also discuss unintended consequences it has on functioning of democracy in India.

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

The anti-defection law was introduced in India via the 52nd Amendment in 1985, Xth Schedule, and corresponding Anti-Defection Law.

It was introduced to curb rising defections and horse-trading, which was impacting stability of govt.

Impact on relationship between political parties and individual legislators 1. Made individual legislators compelled to follow the party whip. 2. Forced individual legislators to vote against their conscience 3. Curbed intra-party dissent 4. Broken link of accountability between voter and his representative → led to less discussions in Parliament 5. Increased the dependence of individual legislators on political parties. 6. Created an alternate extra-constitutional authority inside the House - whips.

Unintended consequences on functioning of democracy 1. Leading to "wholesale defections" (as 2/3rd party defecting is exempt under the act) - (eg.) recently seen in Goa. 2. Disturbs the balance of power between executive and legislature - earlier, private members (both of ruling and opposition party) were at greater liberty to hold the executive accountable. 3. Created a situation in which major decisions of the House may be taken by only a few party leaders → against principles of democracy. 4. Reduced scope for collaboration across party lines in legislature → greater confrontation in parliament → voter interests not represented → against democracy 5. Against separation of powers → giving executive control over legislators (via whip).

Way forward 1. Supreme Court in Keisham Singh Vs Speaker of Manipur (2020) - Speaker disqualification petitions must be decided within 3 months, unless there are exceptional circumstances - Petitions should not be decided by Speaker, but by an independent mechanism 2. Dinesh Goswami committee: - Decision should be by President/Governor, on advice of Election commission - It should be limited to votes where stability of govt is threatened, (eg.) No-confidence motions 3. Political parties must internally establish greater democracy 4. Voter awareness and [a word here is not fully legible in the original, possibly "civic"] education