Topper Copies

Discuss the relationship of the Harappa-Culture with the Vedic Culture. Do you agree with the view that 'Indra' was responsible for the Harappa-Culture. [20 Marks]

Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024

Harappan civilization flourished in the Indian subcontinent in 2000 BCE and its decline began 1800 BCE onwards. The decline of the civilization of this extent was huge and thus historians agree that it happened in phases and over a period of centuries.

Vedic civilization began to emerged after 1500 c. BCE. Thus according to some historians, Harappan culture had no relationship with vedic culture at all. However the condition might not be so easy.

Historians like Romila Thapar and Mortimer wheeler has pointed out that the Early vedic Aryans had invaded the Harappan cities in phases one after other. Aryan invasion was the main cause of the decline of civilization according to wheeler. They cited evidences - 1. It has been stated that 'Indra' was responsible for the decline of Harappan civilization : 2. 'Pundrandhra' or 'Indra', the destroyer of fort as mentioned in Rigveda seemed to be pointing that Indra attacked the fort of Mohenjodaro. 3. Skeletons remains found had also been interpreted as being massacred by the Aryans. 4. City mentioned in 'Rigveda' as Hariyupiya is a understood as Harappa.

However all does not seem to align with this theory. 1. Historians believe that the skeletons found belong to different ages and thus cant be result of Aryan massacre. 2. Aryans came after 1500 BCE, nearly 300 years after decline of Harappan civilization thus there was probably no contact between two.

Even if there was some contact, it did not lead to decline of Harappan settlement but their shift further southwards as - 1. Northward territory occupied by more powerful warrior like Aryans. 2. They won the battle against the natives as mentioned in Rig veda. Natives here can be refered to the people of Harappan civilization. 3. The victory as some believe was led by 'Indra'.

Therefore there are various interpretations to the coming of Aryans and their encounter with the natives that need to be studied with caution.

One thing is clear. The decline of Harappan civilization had been not just due to Aryan Invasion but number of factors. 1. Shireen Ratnagar believed that decline in long distance trade and commerce led to decline of Indus civilization. 2. Irfan Habib gave a political cause for decline that due to fall in the elaborate taxation structure, the empire couldnt sustain itself. 3. Many historians attribute the decline to repeted floods that was annual affair for the people of Indus. 4. W A Fairservice believe over grazing, overirrigation and over exploitation of land as the reason behind decline of agriculture and threatening of civilization.

Recent studies have also thrown light on disappearance of Saraswati river due to tectonic activity leading to famines and thus fall of many cities.

Therefore actual decline has definitely resulted from multi factors and therefore not only can 'Indra' be held responsible for this.