Topper Copies

"The concept of Ashoka's Dhamma as found through his inscriptions had its roots in Vedic-Upanishadic literature." Discuss. [15 Marks]

Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024

Ashoka's Dhamma, which has often been described as a novel concept and an entirely innovative way of life has made Ashoka a man far ahead of his times.

Dhamma as some historians earlier argued was a religion that Ashoka imposed on his subjects. However it was contested by most historians like Romila Thapar and R.S Sharma who believed that Dhamma was not a religion but a way of life that was moralistic and ethically justified. Thus he wanted his subjects to abide by Dhamma.

Principles of Dhamma though novel in name and form, were not new to the Indian subcontinent in subject matter. Dhamma signified => 1. Tolerance towards all beings. 2. Respecting ones elders and Brahmanas. 3. Kind and generous towards all including animals. 4. Devotion to God should be internal phenomenons. There can be many paths to reach God. 5. One should pay taxes and obey the ruler's orders. 6. Animal slaughtering should be forbidden. 7. Conquest should be via peace and not war, i.e., Bherighosa should be replaced by Dhammaghosha. 8. One should not commit violence against others. 9. Punishments should be light in the kingdom. Cruelty as the last resort.

Now all these aspects were more moral and ethical in nature rather than religious in any sense. Despite vedic texts propending for religious chants and praises of heroes and Gods, the 'Vedanta' or the 'last of vedas' had revealed similar ethical and spiritual concepts as propagated by Ashoka. It would be wrong to say that Ashoka copied this from Vedanta or Upanishads which echoed similar philosophical overtone. However some influence of the two oer each other cant be ruled out.

Upanishads and vedanta propagated for - 1. Man's kindness and generosity 2. Truthfulness from within. 3. Inner devotion towards God. 4. Taking care of old parents and respecting them. 5. Living a simple and ethical life. 6. Refrain from slaughtering animals.

Thus it also focuses not on a religion per se but a way of life as done by Ashoka through his Dhamma. who influenced what is matter unclear to us. However roots of Dhamma can directly or indirectly be traced from Vedic Upanishadic literature, at least in some subject matter.