Topper Copies

Critically examine the debates among historians regarding the applicability of the term 'Indian Feudalism' to early Medieval Society.

Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024

Early medieval India according to many historians had been marked by 'decentralization' in polity and economy and thus giving rise to landed magnates in the absence of powerful central authority.

R.S. Sharma had refered to this phenomenon as Feudalism in Early medieval India. He had pointed out that Medieval India the economy became agricultural from urban, caste system became rigid and huge land transfers went in favour of Brahmanas giving rise to 'Urban decay'. There was a decline in urban activity and trade.

D.D. Kosambi has agreed with the view that feudalism was prevalent in Early medieval India.

Harbans Mukhia has observed that the feudal elements were certainly present in Indian Society. However, it would be inappropriate to call it a feudal society as the true elements of feudalism as present in the western society were absent here. He also observed that the agricultural conditions for Indian peasants were different from Europe.

Sharma's view have been contested by D.C. Sircar and B. Chattopadhyay. They have pointed out that there had not been an overall decentralization in Indian polity and economy. Trade and commerce that flourished during Gupta period cannot suddenly stop altogether. Moreover, the land transfers and rise in agricultural economy was benificial as rulers had granted lands to Brahmanas and temples to bring it under cultivation.

K.N. Chaudhury has pointed out that the nature of trade and commerce which was long distance had definitely changed and became short distanced trade. Rather than from Gulf of Aden to Malacca , it became Aden to Persian Gulf , Persian gulf to Cambay, Cambay to Malabar and Malabar to Malacca .

R.S. Sharma and D.D. Kosambi also postulated the feudalism theory on the grounds of 'monetary anaemia' or absence of coinage. This however is contested by John S. Deyell who stated that coins still circulated but there aesthetic quality decreased. Thus it cant be largely refered to as a monetary anemia. Moreover cowry shells and churni was still used .

Sircar, Chattopadhyay and Y. Subbarayalu mentions that the trade must have declined at some places like North India. However it flourished in Tamilakkam, Bengal etc .

Whether to call it feudalism or not is still debated. However, decline of trade was certainly observed with economy flourishing elsewhere since a blanket decline is not possible .

Sharma believed that Brahmana Kshtriya domenance was challenged by vaisyas who prospered during the period from 200 BCE and 300 CE. Thus this hegemony was challenged by vaisyas and Sudras which Sharma linked with 'kali age crisis' as mentioned in Puranas. He said that to protect their position, land grants began to be given liberally to Brahmanas giving rise to feudalism.

Subbarayalu rejected this view stating that only 20% of lands were granted to Brahmanas that too mostly in Tamilakkam. They how can kali age crisis theory be held true on these many land grants only.

Thus while some witnessed decline as evident from some sources, some prosperity certainly witnessed as we know through other archaeological and literary sources .