"The Kalinga was proved a turning point in the career of Ashoka and produced results of far-reaching consequences in the history of India." Elucidate.
Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024
Through various rock edicts of Ashoka including Kalinga Rock Edict and other literary sources of contemporary times, we are aware that Kalinga war proved indeed a turning point in the career of Ashoka.
Ashoka wanted to capture Kalinga as mentioned by historians was due to => 1. strategic location, between Uttarapatha and dakshinapatha. 2. Commercial importance as it had important ports dealing in precious items.
Ashokan rock edict of Kalinga and other Buddhist sources have mentioned that nearly one lakh people were killed in the war. The monks were slained causing utmost misery and havoc of the people of Kalinga.
This had changed Ashoka's mind, gave him immense grief and this change of heart had in a way not just changed his course of actions but had long terms impacts on history that followed.
The Kalinga war was the only war Ashoka fought after ascending the throne. After seeing the pain and misery war inflicted, Ashoka decided => 1. To renounce the policy of war. 2. To replace "Bherighoshe" with "Dhamma ghosha" 3. He continued to conquer territories of far flung areas but this time not through war but cultural amalgamation and exchange 4. He propagated the ideas of Buddhism to various places, constructed Stupas and as Lumbini pillar inscription (Rummindei Pillar inscription) tells us, he also exempted people from Buddha's place of birth from taxation 5. He made himself fatherly figure for his subjects where he treated his people as children 6. His pillar inscription of Erragudi depicted the way of life that Ashoka vowed to preach. He did not want people to convert to Buddhism. He just wanted his subjects to adopt a lifestyle as per values of "Dhamma". Erragudi inscription propagated ideas of respecting elders, taking care of parents, never speeking lies, beeing kind etc. 7. It was not just moral idea that Ashoka spread after the deep impact of Kalinga war. He converted himself into Buddhism and this very event changed the history of Buddhism in India henceforth: - He held the 3rd Buddhist council at Pataliputra. - Constructed stupas - constructed caves for monks - Erected pillar and rock inscriptions.
Therefore history did change its course after a war as devastating as Kalinga war impacted a ruler of Ashoka's stature. Infact some historians like H.C. Roychoudhury believed that Ashoka became a peacemonger and disbanned his army which ultimately led to decline of Mauryan Empire later .
This has been contested by Romila Thapar who stated that Ashoka still maintained strong army, capital punishment etc but did not use it like before and not until need arose. This made Thapar believe that Ashoka was not only an enlightened ruler but also responsible for establishment of first welfarist monarchy .