Critically examine the various views regarding the role of iron technology in ushering Second Urbanisation in Ancient India.
Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024
To many scholars, it was the advent of iron technology in India that became the greatest contributor to the coming of second urbanization. However, the postulate is still debatable.
D.D. Kosambi believes that it was due to coming of iron technology that ganjetic plain could be widely cultivated. He observed that Aryans moved eastwards uptil Bihar to reach iron ore rich areas. This led to development of tools for cultivation. He also pointed out that this led to formation of more advanced weapons and spread of iron led to rise of Magadha.
R.S. Sharma also believes that Majadha became prominent by clearance of forests in the ganjetic area which was done by advent and huge availability of iron ore by 6th c. BCE.
This view has been criticized by several historians. Historians have pointed out that there are no archaeological evidence to prove Sharma's theisis. Moreover, it has been countered on the grounds that evidences from Gwalior to Agra belt had revealed that Atranjikhera revealed iron ore and not as east as Bihar.
Makkhan Lal had observed that the advent of iron technology was very gradual and it was not because of iron that Magadha rose to power. He also pointed out that second urbanization was not due to Gangetic cultivation as Gangetic plains were thickly forested till 16th c. CE
Thus it is debatable as to how far iron technology influenced coming of seccond urbanization. However few facts had been agreed by most historians due to archaeological and literary evidence - 1. Spread of iron ore actually led to some agricultural development in Ganjetic plains 2. This development led to surplus production leading to rise of towns and cities giving rise to seccond urbanization 3. This was mainly driven by vaisyas and sudras who then desired to improve their position in society giving rise to Buddhism, Jainism. 4. when the system became organized, it gave rise to Monarchies
Therefore, the process of coming of second urbanization was multi pronged and evolutionary process.