"Harshvardhan was himself great, but he has been made greater by Ban and Yuan Chiang." Critically examine.
Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024
One of the very few court historiographies came into vogue in early medieval India when Emperor Harshavardhana ascended the throne of Kanauj. His court poet and historians had undoubtedly left us valuable and praiseworthy account without which little had been known to us of him.
Banabhatta is regarded as one of the genius laureles of ancient India. He wrote 'Harshacharita' as a court historian of Harsha. The account gives us important information about life and reign of Harsha which indeed depects greatness of Harsha as a king. However, the account is full of flattery, praises and exaggeration to glorify his patron. 1. Bana has regarded king of kings was Harsha where we know that he held sway only over North India. 2. His military exploits against Sasanka which despite seem true look exaggerated in their way of glorification. 3. Bana wrote that Harsha saved his sister Rajyasri from jumping into funeral fyre of her Husband just as she was about to jump seem dramatic and overglorified . 4. Harsha's cultural and architectural contributions also despite being significant, are overglorified by Bana .
Harshavardhana was a religiously tolerant ruler and was a devout Buddhism . Famous Chinese pilgrim Hieun Tsang who came in the drive for Buddhism and learning was also patronized by Harsha . Hieen had also left us valuable account of Harsha's reign . He had given accounts of economy, society, polity and spread of culture and Buddhism during Harsha in North as well as South India which would otherwise have remained unknown . Some of his accounts are corroborated by Bana and thus reveal authenticity .
However, Hieun was not free from biases and that was evident. 1. He wrote that Harsha held a grand Buddhist council where 8 monks were invited and knowledge on spread of Mahayana Buddhism was given. Hieun said he converted Harsha from Hinayana Buddhist to Mahayana Buddhist which seems exaggeration. 2. Hieun said Harsha was so generous in donations that after the meeting, he gave away to monks all he had including clothes he wore. Thus his general admiration for his master was evident.
Therefore it is evident that flattery and praises had made us believe Harsha far greater a ruler than one would possibly have thought. The accounts of Bana and Hieun, being two primary sources of our study of the period leaves us no choice but to accept them.
However, now that the works of literature are our history, it is evident that Harshavardhana was indeed a great ruler. We have got other details of his administration also like - 1. Religious toleration. 2. Maintained vigilance over all the empire himself, visiting provinces. 3. Donation to Nalanda etc. 4. His books, plays and love for writing. Ex. Ratnavali, Nagananda, Priyadarsika.
We can't totally call the accounts flattery firstly, because it has given minute contemporary details of people and society. Secondly, because at places, flaws of empire has also been revealed. Ex - Hieun wrote that there was law and order problem and he was robbed twice. Also Hieun wrote Buddhism did not flourish everywhere.
Thus one can conclude that Harsha was for certainity a great emperor but was made even greater by two great men of that time namely Bana and Hieun.