Topper Copies

Critically examine the observations of Francois Bernier on Mughal India.

Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024

The accounts of french traveller and polymath Francois Bernier is valuable for our understanding not just of Mughal india but also contemporary western European society.

Bernier had written his accounts in seventeenth century. He had been in company of Dara and after his death, was attached to Aurangzeb's court.

His accounts had left us a lot to analyse critically the empire ⇒

1. Bernier stated that most of the population was rural and were living in extreme poverty. However, contemporary historians believe that nearly 15% population was urban which is more than contemporary Roman urban population. 2. Bernier stated that Hakims and raids had no interest in science and medicinal discoveries and showed no interest when he explained them of Harvey's discovery of blood circulation. 3. Bernier said all the land was owned by emperor and no private property existed. This is not mentioned however in any Mughal document. Perhaps Bernier had misinterpreted it. 4. Bernier had vividly written about people, society, food and beverages, custom and religion of people of Hindustan. 5. Bernier also give insights on the mansabdari and jagirdari system in which exploitation of peasants is depicted which is corroborated by other source.

Despite valuable insights, his accounts cant be fully trusted as he had continuously compared Mughal India with Europe and depicted latter as superior. He had also missed important developments like that in technology. This western biasness should be taken into consideration cautiously.