Evaluate the contents of the Tabaqat-i-Nasiri as a source of medieval history.
Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024
"Tabaqat - i - Nasiri" by "Minhaj - us - Siraj" is a comprehensive document of medieval India capturing the narrative of events, rulers and battles. "Tabaqat - i - Nasiri" as a source of medieval history carries a valuable information. Minhaj had cited the events right from Subuktagin to Muhammad Ghori's invasion on India to the establishment of Delhi Sultanate ending in the mid of reign of At Nasiruddin Mahmud. It is after him that the work has been named.
Book as a source of medieval history => 1. Gives narration of all the important events and battles. 2. Some important events are cited here which are not given in any other source Eg. the Rebellions of Khilji of Bengal. 3. He also give history of rulers of lakhnauti thus not only focused on Delhi. 4. He gives vivid account of Razia's rule. 5. At a time when history writing was rare, his account help us gaining an idea about the society and rulers and help in corroborating facts.
However, there are certain shortcomings in his account => 1. He attribute everything as "will of God". 2. Historical causation is absent. 3. Exaggerations and praises are clearly visible for rulers 4. He gives wrong chronology at certain place.
Despite its flaws, looking at Tabaqat i Nasiri from the perspective of time when it was written, it is undoubtedly valuable.