"The arrival of Portuguese affected existing trade system of Indian ruler and merchants." Elaborate.
Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024
Portuguese were the first Europeans to have reached Indian coasts and eyed its immense trading opportunities here. Portuguese from the beginning aimed at monopolizing the profitable trade of Indian Ocean.
By their arrival, free trade was practiced except some monopolies by Delhi and Deccan rulers. Portuguese established their infamous Cartaz or license system under which they stationed themselves in Goa and all the merchant ships passing from there being compelled to pay license fee to pass. This was applicable to ships going east as well as west. impact it had on existing system => 1. It irked the merchants who felt unnecessary economic burden. 2. Pirates were encouraged by small rulers who looted Portugal ships. 3. Gujarat, Marwari merchants found out way to evade taxes 4. Even Portugal official had low salaries due to their royal monopoly and thus accepted bribes by local merchants. 5. Merchants whose belongings and ships were taken as war prize complained then rulers who posed threat for Portuguese.
Ultimately since Portuguese failed to capture Grey of Aden, then dream of monopolizing Indian ocean trade had failed both due to its vastness as well as the victims' resolute to find alternate ways.
Gradually they had to loosen the the control giving way to the previously practiced free-trade. Thus it became impossible for them to hegemonize the trade which had such vast network from Aden to Malacca.
Trade at Cambay was so vast that Italian historian Varthemia said 200 ships used to come and go from Cambay. Tom Pires stated that Cambay stretched one army towards Aden and other towards Malacca Thus as some western historians believe that it is after Europeans' arrival especially Portuguese that trade in Indian Ocean accelerated does not hold true. Economic historian Omprakash contested this citing that the Indian ocean trade was always vast and flourishing with Europeans just adding on to its commercialization.
Thus the Cartaz system could not last long as it tried to control the flourishing existing system and well developed network of merchants. Ultimately it had to withdraw.