Topper Copies

Give different interpretations of the nature of the Mughal State in Medieval India.

Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024

There has been rigorous debate with respect to the nature of Mughal state and what different school of historians believe it to be. The nature of Mughal state should be seen from Political, economic as well as Religious dimensions.

Regarding the political aspect, western historians like Vincent Smith had observed that Mughal state had been a despotic state forming the dark period in the history of India. He even called Akbar as a despot and his idea of 'sul-i-kul' as a folly to create a group of loyalists.

The argument that Mughal state was an aristocratic is accepted by all. However many historians like J.N.Sarkar and others call it an Enlightened despotism. S.R. Sharma had pointed out that Akbar's religious policy depicted not his folly but his wisdom.

Regarding the economic angle, Historians like Iryan Habib, Satish Chandra and Athar Ali from Marxist school have agreed that Mughal state was a centralized bureaucracy. The state as well as administration was well organized under one pattern and was directly controlled by emperor.

This has been contested by Revisionist historians like Sanjay Subramaniam, Muzaffar Alam and Chetan Singh who pointed out that it is impossible for such a vast empire to be uniformly centralized. After detailed survey of Punjab and Awadh, they concluded the differences in bureaucracy, land revenue system and even administration.

Habib and chandra believed that it was Mughal economy that had uniformly binded the nation into one unit and therefore when this jajmani system was met with crisis, the economy collapsed and the empire declined.

Some historians have given a religious angle to the nature of Mughal state. Historians from Nationalist school like JN Sarkar, A.C. Banerjee and V.S. Bhargava had pointed out that the Mughal state was a theocratic state and religion directed its politics. However Satish Chandra and Athar Ali had contested this. They have pointed out that - 1. There was no mass religious conversions 2. The rulers took their policy decisions seperate from religion and not believed ulema blindly. 3. Most of the decisions against other religious groups also had political motive behind it. Ex. Aurangzeb's order of destructing Hindu temple to take revenge from Rajputs and Marathas. 4. Chandra states that even Aurangzeb became milder during latter part of his reign.

Therefore the debate is still inconclusive and depends on individual interpretations. However few aspects of the nature of Mughal state accepted by most historians are - 1. It was a war state 2. Trade and commerce given utmost importance. 3. Innovative state as innovations kept flourishing : 4. Freedom to people in most aspects. 5. Culture of art, literature and architecture.

Mughal state as even the foreign travellers like Francois Bernier had said was extremely powerful and had greatest portion of Medieval India in its name and fame.