Topper Copies

Q.2 (b) Critically examine the notion of the Mauryan state being a highly centralized system. [15 Marks]

Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024

One of the first true monarchies and perhaps the strongest pan Indian Empire was laid out by the Mauryan Empire of Magadh in the 3rd C. BCE. The extent of the empire was as vast from Shahbazgarhi in Pakistan to Maski in present day Karnataka.

The contemporary sources for study of Mauryan Empire namely, Kautilya's Arthasastra, Megathenes' Indica and the inscriptions of Ashoka has thrown some light on the administration of the empire. On the basis of these three sources, the early historians had concluded that Mauryan Empire was a highly centralized State system. This is because =>

1. The administration was in the sole control of the ruler. 2. He appointed 'Dhammamahamatyas' or officers to propagate his thoughts. 3. He had secret spies directly reporting [?] empire's whereabouts. 4. The emperor had sole control over trade. 5. Economy was controlled by him with respect to minting coins etc. 6. official census of people as well as cattle was taken 7. Arthasastra mentions that ruler should be available for people all the time which later Ashoka also propounded. Thus direct connection of people with ruler. 8. Arthasastra and Indica mentions that all the land actually belonged to ruler and thus he had right to tax. 9. Ruler at authority regarding law and order, judicial matters, crafts and trade etc

Therefore these factors reveal a highly autocratic rule without any decentralization. However, modern historians went a step beyond contemporary sources.

Gerard Fussman argued that it is practically impossible for one ruler to directly rule such a vast an Indian Empire. Chandragupta as well as Ashoka had provincial governors ruling at distant provinces and providing the peripheral kingdoms some autonomy.

Historian Romila Thapar believe that it was like Mauryan Empire had been superimposed on already existing empires. Therefore, what was done was that the emperor directly ruled the core and let local rulers manage periphery till they recognize Ashoka's supremacy or Mauryan supremacy.

Thus though the area under control was ruled strictly, there were disturbed or some far flung areas where power had been devolved due to ease of administration and some decentralization was evident as believed by historians.