Q.2 (a) With the help of literary and archaeological sources, critically evaluate the hypothesis that there was urban decay during c. 300-600 CE. [15 Marks]
Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024
After a flourishing period with rich socio-cultural and economic state of North India, historians believe that it was followed by a gloom in the economic and urban activities.
Prof. R.S. Sharma and D.D. Kosambi believe that period from 200 BCE to 300 CE was culturally and economically prosperous. It was followed by an 'Urban decay' in the words of R.S. Sharma.
Sharma believes that the decay began in Gupta period itself, intensified during later guptas and took full shape in the post Gupta period. 'Urban decay' here means decline in urbanization and flight towards ruralization and agriculture.
Sharma and Kosambi give literary and archaeological evidences to prove the stance ⇒
1. Going archaeologically, this period revealed least coins and inscriptions. 2. Coins during later Guptas like Skanda-gupta and then during Harsha has seen debasement indicating economic crisis. 3. Purana as a literary source mentions 'Kali age crisis' which makes Sharma form 'Kali age crisis theory' where the supremacy of Brahmin and Kshtriya was threatened by Vaisya and Sudra's progress which made former grale more land, leading to decentralization, ruralization and generalization, rise to feudalism. 4. Inscriptional evidences suggest rural descriptions, land grants to Brahmins, expansion of agriculture etc 5. Very few references to crafts men and artisans.
This view has been attacked by Y.S. Subbarayalu and others. He observed that =>
1. Hardly at any point of time, not more than 20% of land was granted to Brahmanas. So with this, Kali age crisis theory cant be held true. 2. Subbarayalu observes that there are evidences in Jatakas and some south Indian later Sangam texts of bustling markets, towns. 3. City of Ujjain was flourishing as evident from literary sources. 4. Bengal forts like Chandraketugarh and Tamralipti were still used for trade as evident from contemporary inscriptions.
Thus Subbarayalu believes that, even if there was an urban decline, it was not uniform throughout the nation. Moreover, the period still witnessed prosperity in few regions.