What factors caused the failure of the League of Nations? Is it correct to say that the League was a complete failure and irrelevant in the World history? Discuss.
Abhijnan Hazarika, AIR 172, 2023
The League of Nations (LoN) was formed in the after-math of the 1st World War with the objective of
- promoting world peace - increasing cooperation between the nations
but it eventually failed as 2nd World War broke out in 1939
Causes for failure of league of Nations (LoN)
- It was largely an Anglo-French affair - USA didnot join LoN as US senate blocked its joining - Germany was not allowed to join till 1926 - USSR was recognised only in 1933. - by the time they joined, Japan had already left LoN - Policy of appeasement followed by the Western powers - led to breakdown of principles of LoNs - eg:- Japan captured Manchuria in 1931 and when LoN asked to vacate it, Japan left LoNs - the Western countries did nothing - was given the impossible task of safeguarding provisions of the principles of Paris Peace - suffered from many defects like eg:- only Germany was considered responsible for the war - lack of resources with the LoN - it had no funds or military of its own and was dependent on the mercy of the constituent nations - its decisions were not binding - there was no way to check whether its decisions were followed by member nations - Great Depression - ensured that not much attention was paid towards the LoNs as attention got directed to economic revival - sidelined by other groups - Conference of Powers of USA, Britain and France in London where major decisions were taken
League of Nations cannot be considered as a complete failure and irrelevant in world history as :-
- Paved the way for formation of UNO :- - by learning the mistakes committed in LoN - Success in other fields - Refugee Commission - Socio-Economic development in member nations. ex:- Health council etc. - not only confined to world peace - Promoted internationalism - which increased international cooperation among member nations in the long run
The LoN failed not mainly because of its system but because of the apathy of its members which eventually led to 2nd World War.