"MGNREGA, lynchpin of rural poverty alleviation, has become victim of fiscal apathy". Critically analyze in light of recent developments.
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
The budget for MGNREGA was cut in Budget 2023-24 by ~15%, in light of revival of economy and employment.
MGNREGA as lynchpin of rural poverty alleviation 1. Safety net: accessible to all adults (100 days work - manual). 2. "Economic shock absorber during COVID" - MGNREGA was able to absorb the burden of rural reverse migration that took place during lockdown. - Data from Ministry of Rural Development: [line graph of person work days (in cr) by year - ~26 in FY19-20, rising to ~36 in FY20-21 and ~38 in FY21-22 during the COVID lockdowns, falling to ~24 in FY22-23] 3. Providing security against seasonal nature of agriculture - farmers join MGNREGA during non-crop season.
"Victim of fiscal apathy"?
Yes: - Budget reduction - Delayed wage payments via PFMS, in some states, in some cases - Lack of work
No: - Demand driven scheme - As can be seen from the graph above: demand increased from 2020 to 2022, then decreased again, in fact decreasing below pre-covid level - Hence, less budget needed - If there is more demand, more budget can be dynamically increased - Govt., Ministry of Rural Dev
NK Singh Panel has pointed out poor fiscal marksmanship, i.e incorrect allocations. Steps such as dynamic allocations, such as for MGNREGA, would improve fiscal marksmanship.